Arduino OPTA
Posted: Thu Nov 16, 2023 3:47 pm
Recently, Sparkfun offered an Arduino OPTA unit for sale.
(https://www.sparkfun.com/products/21279)
As I work on industrial systems for a living, I purchased one of the OPTA RS485 units to test it out. Basically, the unit provides eight analog (or digital) inputs and four relay outputs (along with five LEDs you can control). My original thought is that I could use the unit to digitize data and control components in various research reactors I work on.
Unfortunately, I did not read and understand the specifications that well before purchasing this unit. Although Arduino advertises this a a "professional" unit intended for "industrial applications" it is not really suited for such tasks. The problem is the ADCs (analog to digital converters). While they are quite fast (I was able to read all eight channels in less than 50 usecs), they are not very accurate. The specifications claim 5% accuracy for a 0-10V input range (so an input voltage of 10V should produce a 16-bit result in the range 58,981 to 65,535 (I'm assuming it can't go over scale at the maximum voltage). In other words, it should report a voltage in the range 9.5V to 10.0V. For professional applications, this is terrible accuracy (mediocre devices have an accuracy of 1% and good devices are probably down around 0.1%). Alas, I didn't read the documentation close enough to discover this issue; I figured a "professional/industrial" quality device would have professional specs.
I gets worse, though. The particular unit I purchased seems to be nearly 10% off. I feed it 9.8V and it comes back reporting about 9.01V. Who knows? Maybe I have a bad unit. But even if it were up to spec, it wouldn't be sufficient for controlling a nuclear reactor.
Oh well, back to my own designs...
Cheers,
Randy Hyde
(https://www.sparkfun.com/products/21279)
As I work on industrial systems for a living, I purchased one of the OPTA RS485 units to test it out. Basically, the unit provides eight analog (or digital) inputs and four relay outputs (along with five LEDs you can control). My original thought is that I could use the unit to digitize data and control components in various research reactors I work on.
Unfortunately, I did not read and understand the specifications that well before purchasing this unit. Although Arduino advertises this a a "professional" unit intended for "industrial applications" it is not really suited for such tasks. The problem is the ADCs (analog to digital converters). While they are quite fast (I was able to read all eight channels in less than 50 usecs), they are not very accurate. The specifications claim 5% accuracy for a 0-10V input range (so an input voltage of 10V should produce a 16-bit result in the range 58,981 to 65,535 (I'm assuming it can't go over scale at the maximum voltage). In other words, it should report a voltage in the range 9.5V to 10.0V. For professional applications, this is terrible accuracy (mediocre devices have an accuracy of 1% and good devices are probably down around 0.1%). Alas, I didn't read the documentation close enough to discover this issue; I figured a "professional/industrial" quality device would have professional specs.
I gets worse, though. The particular unit I purchased seems to be nearly 10% off. I feed it 9.8V and it comes back reporting about 9.01V. Who knows? Maybe I have a bad unit. But even if it were up to spec, it wouldn't be sufficient for controlling a nuclear reactor.
Oh well, back to my own designs...
Cheers,
Randy Hyde